Advertisement
•

Paul Goldberger Talks New York & "The Imperfect City"

The Pulitzer Prize-winning architectural critic joins Michelle Young on Untapped New York podcast!

Paul Goldberger Talks New York & "The Imperfect City"
Become a paid member to listen to this article

Pulitzer Prize-winning architectural critic Paul Goldberger comes on the Untapped New York podcast to talk to Michelle Young about his new book, The Imperfect City. They discuss what's great about the Manhattan street grid, growing up in the suburbs of New York City, Jane Jacobs, the Lower Manhattan Expressway ("one of the worst things that has ever been proposed for New York," Goldberger says), and more! 

“A city is not a symphony, composed as a single work,” Paul Goldberger writes. “It is more like jazz, with its mix of order and improvisation.” The Imperfect City is a record of Goldberger’s looking, lingering, and thinking about cities—how they develop their character, how they affect us, and how they change.

On this exhilarating journey around the world, Goldberger points out each city’s notable qualities, from the eco-friendly features of Singapore’s skyscrapers to the collision and coexistence of old and new in Rome, to the boldly imagined lakefront in Chicago. He wanders the picturesque canals of Amsterdam, sets off down the jagged slash of Broadway across Manhattan’s grid, and follows the poetic sweep of Los Angeles’s freeway ramps.

Transcript of Podcast Episode:

Michelle Young (00:07)
Hello and welcome back to the Untapped New York podcast. I'm Michelle Young, the founder of Untapped New York. I'm delighted today to have renowned architectural critic and Pulitzer Prize winner, Paul Goldberger, on the show. Paul, welcome.

Paul Goldberger (00:20)
Thank you, Michelle. Great to be here.

Michelle Young (00:22)
I don't know if you remember this, but you and I were on a Huffington Post live panel back in 2014 about One World Trade Center.

Paul Goldberger (00:29)
Wow. Oh

yes, yes, yes, yes.

Michelle Young (00:33)
For years I actually thought that that

episode was entitled Does One World Trade Center Suck? But actually it had a it had a very

Paul Goldberger (00:39)
It could've.

Michelle Young (00:40)
long title, The Missed Opportunity of the World Trade Tower. And

Paul Goldberger (00:45)
Well, that's a more polite a more polite way of saying the same thing.

Michelle Young (00:48)
Yeah. It was actually the first year that I taught urban studies at Columbia. So I was delighted to be on the show with you and with Aaron Betzky. It's hard to believe it's been 12 years since then.

Paul Goldberger (00:58)
Twelve years. Amazing.

Michelle Young (01:01)
So you have a new book out, The Imperfect City, which to me reads as a pretty deeply personal ode to what you love about cities. And we'll have a chance to talk more about the book. But I would love to first start with what makes you you. So

You were born in a suburb of New York City, I read. Where did you grow up and what was that like?

Paul Goldberger (01:21)
I grew up in a a small town called Nutley, New Jersey, which these days seems to be best known as the hometown of Martha Stewart, in fact. It's really

Michelle Young (01:30)
Ha ha ha.

Paul Goldberger (01:32)
and it was a funny town because it was within commuting distance to New York, and many people, including my father, commuted to jobs in the city, on the other hand.

there were some people there who never went to New York at all and might as well have lived in Ohio, even though it was only ten miles away. Uh so but it was interesting to go up there because it gave me both the sense of being in the shadow of a great city and in a sort of small, distant place. And I I sort of learned about both. Um I actually decided I really preferred the city and have lived most of my life in the city since then.

So I sometimes said I kind of grew up in New Jersey wishing I were on the other side of the river. So

Michelle Young (02:22)
It's funny because I was going to ask you whether Manhattan felt tantalizingly out of reach.

Paul Goldberger (02:27)
It felt absolutely tantalizing and out of reach until it then became in reach and I I started started going there. But it it gave me the feeling that I was you know, I've always felt a little bit like a local and like one of those people who came to New York from far away, even though it was only from across the river, in fact.

Michelle Young (02:48)
Yeah, absolutely. I grew up in Setauket right next to Stony Brook on Long Island.

Paul Goldberger (02:52)
Ah. So you probably had a similar kind of experience of being you know, y y there you were maybe not quite as close, but still, you know, reasonably within the orbit of New York, and yet I'm sure you had neighbors who went to New York all the time and other neighbors who literally never went at all.

Michelle Young (03:10)
Yeah, and the commute was two hours almost on the Long Island Railroad.

Paul Goldberger (03:12)
Mm-hmm. Yeah, which is not a not it was really too far to be a daily commute from Stony Brook Right, right. Mm-hmm.

Michelle Young (03:17)
But some people did it. I interned the summer before I went to college and was shocked by the number of commuters that did this every day. But I think different from you, because it's so far away, I feel like my life, I grew up kind of very ensconced in the Long Island world, but my connection to New York was actually I went to Juilliard pre-college.

Paul Goldberger (03:37)
Oh wow. Wow. Okay. Yes, yes.

Michelle Young (03:42)
That was what made me fall in love with New York City. There's that famous line from F. Scott's Fitzgerald, right? from oh my god what's the name of the book from the yes

Paul Goldberger (03:51)
From the great cats from the great Gatsby Yes, yes, yes.

Michelle Young (03:54)
from The Great Gatsby about coming the the the city seen from the Queensboro Bridge and

Paul Goldberger (03:59)
Yes. Yes.

Michelle Young (04:00)
that was exactly one of the routes that we took in and when I read that in I think seventh grade English class I was like this

Paul Goldberger (04:05)
Mm-hmm, mm-hmm.

Michelle Young (04:07)
is me and so but I think similarly the New York City drew us in it yeah

Paul Goldberger (04:11)
yeah, absolutely.

I mean now my my entry was not the dazzling entry across the Queensboro Bridge, but the Lincoln Tunnel and the Port Authority bus terminal. Uh so in a certain way it's kind of amazing that I got beyond that. Uh I've eventually became very jealous of kids who grew up in Westchester and Connecticut who got to arrive in Grand Central instead. But you know.

Michelle Young (04:35)
Yes, what an arrival. Yeah. But you know what's funny is our colleague here at Untapped New York, Justin Rivers, he came in through New Jersey as well. And he then went to Fordham and he said that one day he was at the Amtrak waiting room, the previous version before they kind of redid some of it. And do you remember that they had these framed pictures of Penn Station just like haphazardly on the columns

Paul Goldberger (05:01)
Mm-hmm, mm-hmm.

Michelle Young (05:02)
there? And he said he it stopped him in his tracks. And he was like, why am I not coming into this station?

Paul Goldberger (05:08)
Right, right, exactly. Exactly. Well he was right. Right, right, right.

Michelle Young (05:13)
okay, so after growing up in New Jersey and maybe wishing you were in New York City, then you went to Yale for art history.

Paul Goldberger (05:20)
I did.

Michelle Young (05:20)
I also studied art history, but at Harvard.

Paul Goldberger (05:22)
Oh right.

Michelle Young (05:23)
so but Yale has always been a real powerhouse for that degree. What was it like to study there in the late sixties, early seventies? Is that correct?

Paul Goldberger (05:29)
Yeah, yeah. I graduated in seventy two. Um, it was great. Uh I studied with Vincent Scully, who was a extraordinary architectural historian and very much became my mentor. And one of the things I'll always be grateful for was that I had the chance to work as an undergraduate with him as closely as if I'd been a graduate student. So it really he was an incredibly important mentor to me. It was

Michelle Young (05:56)
Hmm. And did you get interested in cities in your time there?

Paul Goldberger (06:01)
Um yes, more interested in cities, more interested in architecture. You know, I went to Yale thinking I would I would become a journalist, which I sort of did, but that architecture would really be more of an avocation, just an interest and not my whole professional life. And then as time went on, I realized I was spending most of my time thinking about architecture, looking at architecture. I went to Europe.

uh I think it was the summer between my freshman and and sophomore years and spent just most of my time going around looking at buildings and cathedrals and other things and and then I came back and I decided I was gonna major in that, not in English or whatever and and um my life just kept moving in that direction.

Michelle Young (06:48)
Yeah, I too when I was at Harvard wanted to study architecture urban planning. So there was within the art history major, which they don't even call it a major. They have to call it the history of art and architecture concentration.

Paul Goldberger (07:00)
right. Well mine it was the major was history of art, although I really took mostly history of architecture classes within it.

Michelle Young (07:10)
Yeah, so similar. And then I took a class at the GSD that was the intro to urban planning. But one of the things that

Paul Goldberger (07:17)
Mm-hmm.

Michelle Young (07:18)
I think struck me when I was reading your book about the different academic theories that that come in and out was that I think as students, we don't realize how dogmatic sometimes the schools

Paul Goldberger (07:29)
Yes.

Michelle Young (07:30)
we're at are. And I had wanted to go into urban planning starting as an undergrad, but the class that I took at the time, we studied only the ideal English garden cities.

Paul Goldberger (07:42)
Mm-hmm.

Michelle Young (07:43)
there was a lot of Lewis Mumford, whom you you write about in in your book. And then a lot of it was dedicated to the Big Dig at the time. Yeah. And

Paul Goldberger (07:51)
Ah, right, right, right. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.

Michelle Young (07:53)
So I finished that semester being like, I don't know, I guess this this whole area of study is not for me because I kind of assumed it was the end all be all. I was 19 years old or or something. And then it

Paul Goldberger (08:04)
Yes, yes, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

Michelle Young (08:05)
wasn't until five years later when I went to Columbia just to revisit to see if I wanted to study again and took a class, that I realized that urban planning had suddenly gone quite this international development route, sustainability, a little bit about affordability.

Paul Goldberger (08:24)
Right, right.

Michelle Young (08:25)
and I was like, oh, I guess these studies shift and change. And and that's when I went back into it.

Paul Goldberger (08:31)
Constantly well, I'm glad you did. For we're all we're all glad you did, thanks to Untapped, but but

Michelle Young (08:37)
Thank you.

Paul Goldberger (08:38)
it um it's amazing how dogmatic a lot of education was and sometimes still is. Uh and also how eager students are at a certain point in your life to want a kind of gospel to believe in. I think maybe the most important thing I learned at school beyond what I learned from Scully, who really helped me develop my eye, was another professor who I actually acknowledge in the e in the acknowledgments of this book, a planner named Alex Garvin, who eventually became a very prominent figure in New York. And he was rigidly undogmatic. when I was in school, you know, Jane Jacobs was hardly very recent, but, you know, it was not as old as now. And people were becoming more and more interested in her work. it was he who said, you know, she's mostly right, and there's a huge amount of wisdom in this book, but every word of it isn't right. It's not, you know, don't buy this as a complete package ideologically.

Michelle Young (09:40)
Mm-hmm.

Paul Goldberger (09:41)
And he taught me not to buy anything as a total thought package, as it were, because And I and that and that was in many ways behind this book. You know, that that it's an argument against binary thinking. It's an argument against any complete formula or uh solution that one size fits all cities and one there's one way to deal with it. There's not. Every situation's different. And most formulas, most ideologies, most dogmas turn out to be as full of holes as as they are full of wisdom.

Michelle Young (10:22)
Is there something about this moment in time you felt that this is the book that you wanted to write now?

Paul Goldberger (10:28)
yeah, there is. Um I think it's a lot of it really was my own reaction against the kind of simplistic formulas that drive so much judgment today. And you know, we're certainly seeing that in the political world, which I I don't want to change this into a political discussion,

Michelle Young (10:48)
Yeah.

Paul Goldberger (10:49)
but you know, there's an awful lot of black and white out there. And very few things really are totally black or white. And and so uh the more I listen to planners think planning was the answer. But also the more I listen to, you know, in this country we have a uh great tendency to believe that the free market is the answer to everything. And it's it it's become increasingly clear to me that it's not.

But total control through regulation, through planning, zoning, whatever, has rarely given us the results we want either. And the more I looked at things, the more I realized that, you know, neither one is the answer. And nobody's talking about

Michelle Young (11:40)
Hmm.

Paul Goldberger (11:40)
how we need how we need some of both. And I thought, well, I want to really look at cities around the world and look at how.

intention, which we could call as design, planning, you know, uh regulation too, all part of the same bucket, so to speak, and serendipity and accident work together. And I realize every great city is really a combination of the two. And the cities that are too much one or too much the other both fail in different ways. And and so that that was really the impetus

for the book. And and also, you know, um, there's a brilliant line at the beginning of Jane Jacob's great book, The Death and Life of Great American Cities, where she explains that she's decided to have no photographs at all in this book. So there are no photographs because I want you to read this book and then go out and look around at what you see because the illustrations

for this book are really not necessarily a picture of the thing this sentence is about. The real illustrations of this book for this book are what you see around you. And so go out and look and observe and think about it. And so in a way, I felt that was what I kind of wanted to do here, even though this book does have illustrations about that, but this book is the result of of

observing and thinking about cities for a long time and realizing that in the end their greatness is their inconsistency, their greatness is their incompletion, their greatness is that they don't fit formulas, that they're not like these perfect things, which utopian planners always tried to make, you know, ideal cities. Well, in fact, you know.

The the greatness of New York is that it's not ideal. And so the the title, The Imperfect City, is meant maybe a little bit ironically as a compliment. there's another point in the book where I say, you cities are kind of in the end a little bit like people. You know, we're we're all in the process of becoming and we strive, we're never finished, and we're destined never to be perfect.

Michelle Young (13:57)
Let's talk first about New York City

Paul Goldberger (13:57)
No. Sure, sure.

Michelle Young (14:00)
you give us some examples of what you're talking about, that the accidental, the imperfect parts of New York make it what it is.

Paul Goldberger (14:06)
Sure. Sure.

Well, I could start with maybe the biggest example of all, which is the grid, which is not accidental, it's very intentional. It's one of the m boldest, most assertive acts of planning any American city has ever done. You know, 1811 when New York had barely progressed northward past City Hall, and they're planning this grid of streets all the way up to 155th Street. It was crazy. It was bold, and it turned out to be absolutely correct, of course. But the genius of it is that it's assertive in one sense and yet very full of freedom in another. Because, of course, the grid didn't specify what you put on the grid. It just said this is going to be this larger order of streets that determine much about.

The city, but did not determine everything. And in fact, that you could build all kinds of buildings and do all kinds of things and and neighborhoods could ch still change and evolve and grow. All of that is incredibly important. And it's why the grid turned out to be a great thing. Not because it was restrictive, but because it was so much less restrictive than you would have thought or it would have looked like. So that's one example.

I'll give you two more. Uh I'll start with one that's actually not in the book. It should have been, and I can't think of any reason it's not, except that I thought of it kind of too late and the book was already close to finished and the editor said to explain this will take too much space and we can't change around the pages anymore. And so look at the and and it was incre but I'm gonna so I'll give you a little insight into into the failings of a writer, not just the successes, which is that you do keep thinking of stuff. You try to you think it's finished and then one and but this is I think a a a great example. The Twin Towers of the World Trade Center. When the Port Authority originally conceived of this idea, it was going to be on the East River. And that was where they saw

I don't the but what they thought was potentially the best site. they began to plan it. The Port Authority, as you know, is a joint agency operated by the states of New York and New Jersey in tandem. to do something as bold and expensive as this, the entire board and both governors had to be behind it.

The governor of New Jersey was very skeptical, said, I don't know that this is such a great thing. Why are we putting all this money into this huge pair of towers in New York? so they had to sort of figure out what what could they do for him. Well, he was going crazy over this bankrupt railroad under the Hudson River that was then called the Hudson Tubes, that brought commuters into Manhattan.

it had gone bankrupt. The state was taking it over, the state did not want to spend the money for it. They said to the Port Authority, well, if you take over the railroad and save us the money, uh, we'll okay the World Trade Center. Port Authority said, okay. The railroad came with an enormous parcel of land on the west side, not the east side, which was its terminal, the Hudson and Manhattan Terminals it was called. And

So the Port of Tari said, well, if we're acquiring this and this comes with it, why are we buying land on the other side? This comes with it. We'll put the World Trade Center on that site, as indeed they did. So there who could have planned that? You know, that was a set of circumstances that were rather accidental, uh, but ultimately affected the destiny of the city. Um and would have even before long before the tragedy of 9-11, it affected the destiny of the city.

Another one, also in Lower Manhattan, that is very much in the book, em this is an important part of the story in the book. You know, one of the worst things that has ever been proposed for New York was Robert Moses' idea for the Lower Manhattan Expressway, connecting the Holland Tunnel to the Williamsburg and Manhattan Bridges, which would have wiped out Soho. Thankfully, of course, it didn't happen.

But it was in the planning stages for years. People were fighting about it for years. There was a long, long period when basically a sort of Damocles was suspended over Soho. The owners of buildings there.

couldn't sign any leases because they didn't know when, what if the expressway got appr approved? And the city came to them and said, okay, you have 30 days to empty your building and we're gonna we're about to start again. So no one was gonna sign a 10 year lease or put any money into those buildings. So they just kind of mostly sat there. But the people who were happy to use those buildings on a month to month basis because they couldn't afford

To sign 10-year leases anyway, were artists. And they were perfect artist studios. So artists started colonizing Soho. We all know where that story ended, of course. You know, it became one of the greatest examples of urban gentrification, with all both the good and the not always so good meanings of the word gentrification. In the history of

America, if not the world, and a kind of poster child for renewed neighborhood of old great architecture. but the roots of it actually lay in the terrible idea to do the expressway. Um would it if if the expressway had never been planned, would it have evolved this way? Maybe. We don't know.

But it we certainly know it wouldn't have evolved in exactly that way on that same timeline. So, you know, there you see this wonderful way in which just unintended, it's kind of a little bit about the law of unintended consequences, which is you could say is maybe the first law of urban planning, the law of unintended consequences. Um, you know, and and then of course, you know, the artists did indeed kind of colonize Soho. Happily, uh that

Coincided with the surge of interest in historic preservation. People were more became more and more aware that the inventory of cast iron buildings in Soho from the 19th century was unmatched literally anywhere in the world. And that this had to be saved, which became, of course, yet another of the arguments against the expressways. If you needed more, that way there was yet another. And in time it became a historic district. The landmarks commission was established. It it designated Soho. Soho went from being, you know, a place of artist studios and galleries to being unfortunately a little too much like an upscale mall. uh But nevertheless, uh it remains a vibrant and healthy neighborhood, even though many of the people who could have uh rescued it originally were driven out by rising prices. So so you know there you the and and and no planner had anything to do with any of this. Until later when regulation in the form of zoning and historic landmark status began to save it.

Michelle Young (21:36)
Right. So do you think the overall solution potentially is framework with freedom or freedom within framework?

Paul Goldberger (21:46)
Yes, I think that's I think that is exactly right. Now, that the circumstances, of course, are always a little different every place. And so I think, you know, the the real lesson is one needs to study the precise circumstances, not come in with a predetermined set of ideas, not come in with a certainty of result, but come in with a willingness to study and look at the reality in front of you. And what can we take from it? What can we learn from it? What does it suggest? What are its fundamental qualities that we may we may want to preserve? But also knowing that if a city can never be frozen in time completely, if it's frozen it's dead. But change has to be managed too, you know. I mean there's one point in the book where I say a city a city is a natural organic thing. but that doesn't mean you just let anything happen. A garden is also a natural organic thing. But you know what a garden will look like if nobody gardens it for t six months. I mean it's it's a horrible mess of weeds and you know, kind of disgusting. So a city needs to be gardened, but it is still a natural thing and the garden needs to be allowed to grow too.

Michelle Young (23:09)
It's funny because that phrase that I use, or some variation, is actually how the French mention or talk about child upbringing. I know there's always a lot of debate between the American way of raising children and the French way, but that's the f

Paul Goldberger (23:21)
Right, right, right, right, right, right, right.

Michelle Young (23:23)
that's the phrase they use, kind of freedom within a boundary or freedom within a frame.

Paul Goldberger (23:27)
And I think I think it is, it's right though. And you know, I mean, uh and I think it is uh it is absolute freedom within a boundary is in fact, if you had to reduce it to a phrase, I think

Michelle Young (23:40)
Yeah.

Paul Goldberger (23:40)
That's probably about as good a phrase as I could come up with. I wish we'd had this conversation when I was still writing the book. I would have quoted you in it.

Michelle Young (23:53)
So in terms of New York City, when we have a pure free market, which is not exactly what we have either, but I think in right.

Paul Goldberger (24:01)
Right. Nor do we want a totally pure free market, because we've already learned that, you know, a free market will not solve our housing problem, it will not solve a lot of things. On the other hand, a completely controlled market won't work either.

Michelle Young (24:16)
Yeah, and I I don't know if this is or you would agree, but it feels like in the last few decades we have swung more towards a bit of a free market model.

Paul Goldberger (24:28)
Yes, yes.

Michelle Young (24:29)
And your opinion, what has that led to?

Paul Goldberger (24:32)
well, I think we are now in a period of reacting against that.

Michelle Young (24:37)
Okay.

Paul Goldberger (24:38)
Or we're at least at the beginning of the reaction against that because we have seen that the completely free market is not solving our problems. That it does not provide enough housing, it does not provide enough schools, it certainly does not provide enough health care, which is, you know, less of not a city planning problem so much as a societal problem. But uh on the other hand, we also know that places in which total regulation has been the norm have not worked for different reasons. But you know, the the pendulum was certainly swinging in a different direction at in the time when we

Built most of our public housing in New York. And when it was understood then that the market was not going to take care of this problem, and we needed to intervene in a certain way to, in fact, solve this problem and have enough housing for those who could not afford the market rate. You know, the housing market is both the triumph and the tragedy of America in in different ways because it has meant that those who were fortunate enough to get in when values were lower have had this, you know, vast increase in their resources and their in their net worth. but it also means so many more are excluded, including, you

Michelle Young (26:04)
Right.

Paul Goldberger (26:05)
know, hard working people with jobs. We're not just talking about people who cannot support themselves. We're people who we're talking about people who who work hard ought to be able to support themselves, except the structure economically of of things makes that not so feasible. So yeah,

Michelle Young (26:25)
Right.

Paul Goldberger (26:26)
and and but now we're in a time where not only is the government not building housing as it did in the heyday of know public housing in the mid-20 uh rather in the you know New Deal and and onward period, we can't even afford to maintain that which we have. You know, as as as you know, the you know New York City Housing Authority which which owns thousands and thousands of housing units without which the city would be in in far worse shape than it is now, cannot afford to maintain them properly. Those are buildings that um, you know, desperately need maintenance. Because another thing, again, not to go back to the old garden analogy, but you know, it is true of any building everywhere, that the design and construction of it is only the first step and then you know, the best building in the world will fall apart if it's not taken care of. Buildings really need care and care costs money and and you know the the structure of a building is likely to last longer than the elevators and the refrigerators and the sinks and the stuff in it and or the pipes and all that stuff needs to be maintained and often replaced. And and so we can't do that and that's a big big issue.

Michelle Young (27:53)
Mm-hmm. Yeah. And it's it's also about the timing in which those units originally became available that that people had access to that. But if we're not adding more to the stock at the same rate, then right.

Paul Goldberger (28:01)
Right, right. Precisely. We are not. We are not. So so, you know, we we not only don't have the money to repair those units and care for them properly, we don't have alternate places for the people in them to live, even if we had the money and said, Okay, you know, this building's gonna have a complete gut rehab, it'll take a year and a half.

Everybody move out and move into this building and then we're gonna do it and then you can move back. It'll be great, except we don't have the money to do it and we don't have the other building for them to move into either. So you know, it just keeps on declining. And meanwhile, you know, the problem gets worse because there are more people with more urgent needs.

Michelle Young (28:51)
The other thing that struck me about allowing the free market is it causes a certain homogeneity in design. And you address that in your book as well, this sort of internationalization

Paul Goldberger (29:00)
Yes. Yeah.

Michelle Young (29:02)
of design that has occurred. And I remember about 10 years ago or so, I took a boat ride with people from New York City Planning and Design Commission and such. Because they all a lot of them also teach at Columbia. So we were all on this boat ride together.

Paul Goldberger (29:12)
Yeah, yes, yes.

Michelle Young (29:17)
And I spoke to one of them, a friend of mine, and I said, Why so much blue glass? And what was interesting was I actually felt that it struck him almost for the first time, seeing it from a distance. Because I feel like when you're working in that field for the city, maybe you're evaluating all these individual projects and assessing how they might

Paul Goldberger (29:39)
Right, no.

Michelle Young (29:40)
fit in. But then maybe it did feel like it hit him for the first time as he saw it all in construction. And I think that was probably around the Hudson Yards time construction and things around there on the west side. And yeah,

Paul Goldberger (29:50)
Yeah. Oh yeah. Well totally true. Mm-hmm.

Michelle Young (29:54)
and then I feel like since then there really has become this really internationalization of style. So a lot of stuff that's built could feel like it could belong anywhere in the world. And so with this problem question

How do we balance that? Because we also don't want to be too prescriptive in terms of design,

Paul Goldberger (30:11)
Right.

Michelle Young (30:12)
like you have to have this type of exterior material. And we we've seen how that plays out around the country.

Paul Goldberger (30:16)
Right, right. Well, you know, it how that plays out, not always great, although, you know, at the end of the day, I will probably take Battery Park City over Hudson Yards, however. You know, Battery Park

Michelle Young (30:29)
Mm, mm-hmm.

Paul Goldberger (30:30)
City is very prescriptive, maybe a little too prescriptive, it's very self conscious, it does try a little too hard, but you know, it's earnest. And Hudson Yards

Michelle Young (30:41)
Mm-hmm.

Paul Goldberger (30:41)
is not earnest. And maybe so th there's there there there's that important difference, I think. Um

Michelle Young (30:48)
th that word earnest is so interesting. I hadn't even put it in those terms, but I have spoken about different projects that people may have found controversial, but I said at least it's saying something different.

Paul Goldberger (30:59)
Yes! And it kind of means well. And and you know, there's a I mean, I don't wanna now look, we all know the road to hell is paved with good intentions and and we don't wanna we don't wanna like make too many excuses for effort, but even so, uh you've gotta you've gotta give some credit for the kind of seriousness and decency of intention behind a lot of stuff.

And and I really feel that in the case of Battery Park City, that there really was an earnestness, a desire to do the right thing. however, you know, we might question some of the results. So you have to give it some credit. You know, the bigger question you're asking though is a really important one, and I don't have a clear answer because it, one of the reasons we see a lot of things that look like Hudson Yards is because so much real estate today is financed by global capital, by, you know, huge, huge pools of investment capital that kind of wash around the globe. And they're not financed by local developers going to local banks

To pay for buildings in neighborhoods in which everybody who's part of the project has a vested interest in what happens. You know you could have some investment fund investing in projects done by a global development company in New York. Do they care what happens in that neighborhood? No. They really don't. They care about how much return they're gonna get per square foot on a building. And that's that's a very big issue because i i the answer is not simply to say that all forces of globalization are bad and we retreat and we we we we we know how that turns out, not well. I mean, you know, we we are all interconnected.

But, if we don't recognize that we pay certain prices for that. And, you know, we we know, I mean, there's a lot of talk about how the super tall apartment buildings are not occupied very often, or to to much of a degree, by people who really live there. that's of absolutely true, but that's only the tip of the iceberg of this particular problem, which is that they're constructed.

Almost with that purpose in the first place. You know, it's not just that they happen to be bought by people who have six houses around the world and don't spend much time there. It's more that they're all they're really constructed to serve that by people who are maybe even less interested in the neighborhood than the people who buy the apartments. Because the people who buy those apartments.

You know, a couple of times a year at least they walk around the neighborhood and they care what it's like. Whereas the people sitting in their office across the world really don't ever.

Michelle Young (34:04)
the day that I opened your book was also the same day the New York Times published its article about glass skyscrapers and the motivation behind building them, the persistence of them. And also they were looking at its sustainability aspect, especially in the Middle East. And it struck me because you were writing about some of that, and then here's this article. And so I had wondered if part of that maybe can be solved through some sustainability initiatives, because if it's very unsustainable to have such large glass buildings and there is some regulation, I don't know.

Paul Goldberger (34:40)
Yeah, um, maybe, but you know, the reality is that glass is uh less unsustainable than it used to be.

Michelle Young (34:49)
Mm.

Paul Goldberger (34:49)
I mean I don't like seeing buildings of glass everywhere either. So I'm not, you know, I'm not trying to give it a pass here. I'm just saying it's a maybe a tougher problem because the technology of glass has continued to make great advances.

The glass curtain walls that you see and I see and that neither of us likes that much in new buildings are much more sustainable than a lot of earlier ones. You know, they're thicker, they have more layers of glass, they're much more energy resistant. I mean th you know, they they don't let in heat as much, they don't let in cold as much, they don't let out you know, they're not porous

So unfortunately, I don't think sustainability is going to be quite as good an answer. Not because sustainability doesn't matter. It's because the glass industry has actually done pretty well in improving. In the same way, here's an analogy for this. the automobile industry has done phenomenally in improving sustainability.

not only in the move to electric vehicles, but gas vehicles get much better mileage than a generation ago that they did. Does that solve the problem of too much traffic and of cities being too oriented

Michelle Young (36:04)
Mm-hmm.

Paul Goldberger (36:04)
toward the automobile and of highways being built where they don't belong? No. We have to solve that one in a different way. Same with this, I think. It it's not going to solve it by itself, even though sustainability is every bit as important as you're saying it is.

Michelle Young (36:19)
Yeah. Okay. So the diversity of architecture will be solved through some other mechanism.

Paul Goldberger (36:23)
Through some other means. And and you know, look and it that has always fascinated me and it took me a long time to realize and I don't have a r I wish I had a better answer for this. Glass glass has made for some of the most beautiful buildings that have ever been built. But the reality is the Seagram building, let's say, perhaps the greatest

Michelle Young (36:44)
Mm.

Paul Goldberger (36:45)
glass tower ever built in New York, looked much better when it was surrounded by masonry buildings and it was like this perfect jewel glistening amid the stone around it. the minute you make an entire city of glass, something's different. Something, you know, there's something kind of brittle about it. There's something that is off-putting. There's something that does not feel as warm and unnatural about it. So glass which makes these very beautiful objects does not make whole cities or streets very well. Um and and I I don't really have an answer to how we uh take that piece of knowledge and turn it into policy actually and use it to make a difference. I wish I did, but if you read this book carefully you'll see that it kind of complains about that without actually solving it very well.

Michelle Young (37:43)
Well, there's an importance in raising the question too. Okay, so we talked

Paul Goldberger (37:45)
Yes, yes, yeah, right, right.

Michelle Young (37:47)
about diversity of architectural design. How

Paul Goldberger (37:50)
Yeah.

Michelle Young (37:51)
about diversity in terms of population? And I'm not just talking race, but New York

Paul Goldberger (37:55)
Right.

Michelle Young (37:56)
City we consider a very diverse place on on many levels, and it seems to be an ideal that's in important to you. So any solutions on on how we can maybe

Paul Goldberger (38:02)
It's very important. And well, no, no. I don't mean no solutions. There are solutions, but and I think we're we're working toward them now. And although I'm not sure, you know, I agree with every last thing our new mayor has said, I think he's certainly very aware to and alert to this and eager to see it addressed properly. and working to do so.

The diversity that we have always struggled with in New York, and do so now more than ever, is not racial or cultural diversity, it's economic diversity. Because it is it is too difficult to live in this city if you do not have a lot of money. it's one of the reasons that the nineteen seventies in New York were a troubled and very difficult time in many ways, but not a simple, once again, not simply black and white, not not purely awful. End of discussion. Yes, the city was dangerous. Yes, it was economically depressed. Yes, it was dirty. Yes, there was not enough of a sense of a public realm at all.

We're better on all those counts than we were then. But when things were bad, they were also cheap. And it was a very vibrant period culturally. Because, you know, if you were a young filmmaker, a young actor, a young writer, as I was, a young dancer, a young artist, you could afford to be here. And you were. And it made for a a place with a lot of cultural energy.

I also I feel very lucky in a weird way that that that that time gave me a chance to raise my three kids in a nice big apartment on the west side.

And and I you know, when I was a a journalist, Uh, you know, now you'd have to be a partner at Goldman Sachs to do that. And and so and and you know, a lot of the people of a certain generation who represent diversity in New York are people who are here because they got in when the stakes were lower and you could afford it. And so that's a problem that in some ways only gets worse. because as people who you know, who came in in those years, uh, who maybe were artists, journalists, teachers, what have you, move on, in some cases die eventually, whatever, they tend to get replaced by a less and less diverse group of people. and, you know, the the West Side building that I lived in for so many years and where my kids grew up, now

It's still a beautiful, wonderful place, but it's it's less heterogeneous than it used to be. It's now, you know, every time somebody sells an apartment, it gets bought by yet another Wall Street person. So that that's a form of diversity that we are losing in New York, even as we strive toward other kinds of diversity. And and you know, the only maybe offsetting or redeeming aspect to that is that, you know, there are more and more neighborhoods that are becoming uh interesting and diverse in different ways. I mean, there are parts of Brooklyn that now are are much more interesting and remain affordable, the barely in some cases. And and

Michelle Young (41:37)
Yeah.

Paul Goldberger (41:38)
a lot of them are losing it fast too.

Michelle Young (41:41)
I know I live in Crown Heights and got in at a time where could buy something. Now the townhouses on my block are selling for 3.2 million. And that's Crown Heights. And you've once you calculate it, you're like, what's the 20% down? Who has that money? Then the actual mortgage monthly, you're like, this hasto be a banker, but now he's choosing to live in Crown Heights.

Paul Goldberger (42:08)
Right, well well that's because, you know, in Tribeca it's two or three times that amount of money. That's why you know, um or Brooklyn Heights is two or three times that amount of money. And so yes, no I mean that you know, I don't think that's what trickle down was supposed to mean, actually.

Michelle Young (42:28)
No.

Paul Goldberger (42:29)
Trickle down economics was not supposed to mean that the the the banker lives in Crown Heights.

Michelle Young (42:38)
Nor does that mean diversity, right?

Paul Goldberger (42:41)
Right, right.

So, you know, I mean look, it's i some aspects are great. Yes, you know, it is wonderful that there are fantastic places to like eat and shop

Michelle Young (42:52)
Mm-hmm.

Paul Goldberger (42:53)
all over Brooklyn in a way there weren't once before. all that is good. Um and yes the ebb and flow and continued life of the city is reaffirmed. But i ebb and flow

just as a concept seems to suggest things moving in all directions rather than just pfft like that. And so, you know, ebb and flow and rushing river are not the same thing. And so So

Michelle Young (43:21)
Yeah, we'll leave that to our our planners to figure out. Your book also covers Paris and Singapore. So I want to briefly talk about Paris because I'm actually quite familiar. My husband is from there and I wrote a book about my last book is about Paris during World War II, not from a planning perspective. Yeah, it's a World War II true story nonfiction of a spy.

Paul Goldberger (43:3
Fantastic. Oh I have to read that. Oh wow.

Michelle Young (43:46)
Yeah, it's called the Art Spy. So I go there very frequently, especially when I was working on the book as well. One of the things that has really struck me about Paris is that outsiders who are not from Paris love all the urban initiatives that have happened. Like I see the videos, I see friends go and they're amazed by the bike lanes and the greenery. But for some reason, Parisians are very angry about it. So I don't know if you you experienced any of that when you were researching, but I also want to know what you love about Paris.

Paul Goldberger (44:15)
Yeah. Sure, Um I mean, look, I I I know there's some anger about it, as there is in New York too. And some of it is just general resistance to change that particularly people who are very embedded in the city often have wherever they are. some of it may be that, traffic does get squeezed a little bit.

I mean I think there's even less of an excuse to drive a car in Paris than there is in New York because exactly. Yes, yes, yes.

Michelle Young (44:42)
It's terrible. Anytime I've taken an Uber, I've regretted it. But just sometimes you have too much suitcase or something. And but every time I get in, I'm like, this is the worst.

Paul Goldberger (44:51)
I was very proud of myself. The last time I was in Paris earlier this year I I actually took the metro to the train to de Gaulle and

Michelle Young (45:02)
Yeah.

Paul Goldberger (45:02)
and avoided an Uber entirely and but yes, it is uh it did mean lugging a suitcase down a flight of stairs and and a few blocks

Michelle Young (45:11)
Yeah.

Paul Goldberger (45:12)
all that all that stuff. Totally. I think what I've always loved in Paris more than anything is the streets. I mean it is a it is the greatest reminder we have of the fact that in any city the street matters more than the building. You know, it is it is the street, the life of the street, the way in which the idea the street is so deeply embedded into the culture of the place. and it's why I would rather walk than do anything. And it's why also probably uh it was painful to be there this June when um it was a hundred and one degrees Fahrenheit in Paris and uh walking was not nearly the pleasure it usually is. But

Michelle Young (45:55)
Yeah. Yeah. There's been a lot going on in Paris. I was there in July.

Paul Goldberger (45:59)
Mm-hmm.

Michelle Young (45:59)
Paris was fine, but I had to actually battle my way through the wildfires and got
within like two kilometers of it or something. It was it was wild. And I was trying to move my kids down to their grandparents. And yeah,

Paul Goldberger (46:07)
That's that's scary, yes. wow. Wow, yeah, yeah.

Michelle Young (46:13)
I think it was like the first moment a long time that I was struck by just how apocalyptic it was. I got out of the train station in Bordeaux and there was ash falling and we couldn't breathe.

Paul Goldberger (46:21)
Yes, yes. No, it it is scary and and Europe in general, despite the fact that uh they're they are far more willing to acknowledge the impact of climate change than we are in this country, or or at least some of us are in this country. nevertheless, uh I think they are facing a more severe set of impacts than we are here.

I mean the the fact that summer in Europe has become uh dangerously hot when they are not particularly equipped to deal with it, they you know, it it is is very concerning.

Paul Goldberger
I spent a lot of one day in, one of the reasons I was there when I was was I wanted to see the Calder show at the Fondation Louis Vuitton which of course is not only a great piece of architecture, but a relatively recent building with um extremely effective air conditioning. So uh I spent even longer and delved even more deeply into Calder than I might have otherwise because it was so comfortable there.

You at least hopefulness. Um you know, you have to be at least somewhat hopeful or it's too hard to get up in the morning, you know. It's I mean you just stay in bed and be depressed. And and so uh y you have to try to do what you can do. and you know, I don't know that we're gonna solve all of these problems any more than we are gonna solve all of our political problems or our housing problems or our healthcare problems. But, you know, what are we if we don't keep trying, you know? I mean I I I was very moved by something somebody said to me, I don't remember who I would give them credit, that um you you know, you have to realize at some point that you alone cannot fix the world.

But you can try to set a good example.

And and I love that too. I mean it just says, okay, you know, what any one person can do is set a good example. And if everybody set a good example, we would fix the world. But

Yes. Right. No, we do not at all. And in fact, again, you know, itconsist cities are not supposed to be consistent. Um Aristotle once said, you know, a place of all like minded people is not a city. Um you know, there th diversity of thought, diversity of of uh life, diversity of interest, uh diversity of taste.

Those are all essential to a city and and they make they make life more interesting. It's kind of boring to be around people who are exactly like you. You know, I mean, yeah, every now and then it's okay, but you you get pretty bored pretty fast if you were in a little colony of identical people. And and so I think cities are about the idea of common ground within diversity. You know, we find

Common ground we all feel a sense of vested interest in this place. And it represents us even as we are all different and we want different things out of it.

Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Michelle.

Advertisement
•

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.

Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.

You've successfully subscribed to Untapped New York.

Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.

Success! Your billing info has been updated.

Your billing was not updated.